- Open Access
Childhood physical abnormalities following paternal exposure to sulfur mustard gas in Iran: a case-control study
Conflict and Health volume 4, Article number: 13 (2010)
Mustard gas, a known chemical weapon, was used during the Iran-Iraq war of 1980-1988. We aimed to determine if exposure to mustard gas among men was significantly associated with abnormalities and disorders among progenies.
Using a case-control design, we identified all progenies of Sardasht men (exposed group, n = 498), who were born at least nine months after the exposure, compared to age-matched controls in Rabat, a nearby city (non-exposed group, n = 689). We conducted a thorough medical history, physical examination, and appropriate paraclinical studies to detect any physical abnormality and/or disorder. Given the presence of correlated data, we applied Generalized Estimating Equation (GEE) multivariable models to determine associations.
The overall frequency of detected physical abnormalities and disorders was significantly higher in the exposed group (19% vs. 11%, Odds Ratio [OR] 1.93, 95% Confidence Interval [CI], 1.37-2.72, P = 0.0002). This was consistent across sexes. Congenital anomalies (OR 3.54, 95% CI, 1.58-7.93, P = 0.002) and asthma (OR, 3.12, 95% CI, 1.43-6.80, P = 0.004) were most commonly associated with exposure. No single abnormality was associated with paternal exposure to mustard gas.
Our study demonstrates a generational effect of exposure to mustard gas. The lasting effects of mustard gas exposure in parents effects fertility and may impact child health and development in the long-term.
Sulfur mustard gas [bis(2-chloroethyl)sulfide], first synthesized in early 1800 s, has been used in several major wars, and is a common chemical warfare agent . Iraqi forces used it against civilian populations during the 1980-1988 Iran-Iraq war [2, 3].
Although mustard gas can have severe systemic effects on humans , it is best known as a skin vesicant. In a series of approximately 34,000 Iranian patients exposed to mustard gas, the lungs, eye, and skin were the most common sites of injury, in order of the greatest prevalence [4, 5].
Beside its acute effects, mustard gas has a number of known long-term effects on various body organs such as lung, stomach, bone marrow, and gonads [6–11]. In addition, sulfur mustard has been shown to influence the reproductive function in both animals and human being [9, 12–14]. It is a potent carcinogen and mutagen . However, there is little information about parental exposure to sulfur mustard and congenital anomalies in the offspring.
We aimed to estimate the frequency of physical abnormalities and disorders among the progenies of men in a major urban setting (Sardasht City) exposed to sulfur mustard gas. We aimed to compare the prevalence of observed abnormalities and disorders with those of a non-exposed population.
Subjects and setting
We began this study in 2004, about 17 years after the chemical attack in Sardasht. We followed children up to March 2009. Sardasht is a western Iranian city that was chemically bombarded with sulfur mustard gas (HD) by Iraqi forces on June 28, 1987. Documents maintained by military and civil authorities in Sardasht region confirm that approximately 8025 inhabitants were exposed to mustard gas and approximately 4500 people received medical treatment. Of these, records confirming early clinical manifestations of exposure and subsequent medical complications were available for 735 male survivors .
All Sardasht men that had a confirmed history of mustard gas exposure were selected and their progenies, who were born at least nine months after the exposure were considered as the exposed group. However, children whose both parents had confirmed history of exposure to mustard gas were not included in this study.
Since Iraqi forces attacked Iranian soldiers and civilians with various chemical agents several times, a special commission was assigned by Veteran Affairs Organization to confirm the chemical exposure and to determine the severity of injury. This commission consisted of a pulmonologist, a dermatologist, a neurologist, and an ophthalmologist that based their decision on hospital documents, mustard gas exposure stigmata, and clinical signs and symptoms of chronic complications of exposure, and appropriate paraclinical studies as required for diagnostic confirmation. All Sardasht men studied had official confirmation of chemical exposure from this commission. These patients were contacted using the Veteran Affairs Organization's database and by placing signposts and billboards across the city.
Rabat is a nearby city that has ethnic, cultural, and geographical characteristics similar to Sardasht but was not exposed to chemical attack. Rabat is 20 Km from Sardasht, and according to governmental documents, no proven traces of chemical agents were found in the Rabat region. There is no difference in access to medical care between the two regions. In this study, 164 couples from Sardasht were frequency matched by age with 136 couples from an existing cohort from Rabat. The initial groups were larger due to differences in the age distribution, we used a random number table to remove randomly several cases and controls to obtain a similar distribution of individuals in each age group.
We developed an interview sheet and a checklist as data-gathering tools. Our data collection included demographic data of all chemically injured males and their spouses in the exposed (Sardasht) group, age, occupation, educational level, date of marriage; close relative marriage, and any history of chemical injury. The same data was also gathered from the non-exposed (Rabat) group.
Trained general practitioners (GPs) evaluated medical histories from all progenies born at least nine months after the date of the chemical exposure in both exposed and non-exposed groups. In addition, the GPs performed a complete physical examination. If any physical abnormality or special disorder was suspected, the progeny was referred to a pediatrician to confirm the diagnosis. If the pediatrician considered additional diagnostic tools necessary for confirmation, paraclinical studies (e.g. echocardiography, spirometry, various imaging techniques) were performed.
Based on these examinations and confirmatory paraclinical studies, various abnormalities were identified and recorded. All abnormality entities were coded based on International Classification of Diseases, revision 10 (ICD-10) and/or disorders were classified as follows: diseases of the blood; endocrine, nutritional and metabolic diseases; mental and behavioral disorders; diseases of the nervous system and epilepsy; diseases of the eye, adnexa, ear and mastoid process; diseases of the circulatory system; diseases of the respiratory system; diseases of the digestive system; diseases of the musculoskeletal system; diseases of the genitourinary system; and congenital malformations. Whenever any disagreement occurred between the diagnostic opinion of GPs and the pediatrician, the pediatric diagnosis was accepted. In addition, if a progeny had a history of physical abnormality and disorder based on medical records but had normal physical exam at the time of the present study, due to previous medical treatment or surgical management, they were included as an event. Physical abnormalities or disorders were defined as any abnormality that can be detected by medical history, physical exam, or paraclinical studies.
Our sample size estimation was based on 95% power, a two-sided alpha (0.01), and an expected difference of 10% with a continuity correction. We provide descriptive statistics on the populations as groups. To take into account the correlation between families, we used SAS GENMOD procedure (SAS 9.2 SAS, Gary, NC), assumed a binomial distribution, logit link function and an exchangeable correlation matrix type.. We provide point estimates as Odds Ratios (ORs) with 95% Confidence Intervals (CIs). We used 2-sided P-values.
Two hundred and eighty-three couples had official confirmation of exposure to Sulfur Mustard gas. Of these, in 193 couples only the male partner was chemically injured at least nine months before conception. Nineteen of these men were infertile (primary infertility in 12 men); of the seven men with secondary infertility five men had become infertile after the exposure; one was infertile before exposure and the data of the last one was not available. Ten were older than 65 years at exposure. Therefore, this study included 164 couples as designated exposed group. The non-exposed group, also, consisted of 136 age-matched couples. General characteristics of exposed and non-exposed groups are summarized in Table 1.
Of a total number of 498 progenies born at least nine months after chemical attack in the exposed group, 291 (58%) were males (male/female ratio: 1:1.40). In Rabat, 689 children were born at least nine months after the date of Sardasht bombardment; 350 (50%) were males (male/female ratio: 1:1.03). Children in the non-exposed group were slightly older than their counterparts in the exposed group (10.6 standard deviation (SD) 4.7 years and 9.0 SD 4.7 years, respectively, P = < 0.0001). In both groups, the minimum child's age was 0.1 year and maximum age 16 years.
Based on the medical history, physical examination, and paraclinical studies, a comparative listing of abnormalities was prepared between the exposed and non-exposed groups. This list and related ICD-10 coding is provided in Table 2. In addition, the numbers of progenies whose abnormality was confirmed by medical history but were partially or completely normal at the time of physical examination because of prior medical intervention were 32 (6.4%) and 20 (2.8%) in the exposed and non-exposed groups, respectively (P = 0.19).
In the exposed and non-exposed groups, 120 (24%) and 52 (7.5%) patients were referred to the pediatrician for further investigation and confirmation of diagnosis. After this second-level assessment, the overall frequency of evaluated abnormalities and disorders in the exposed group was significantly higher than the non-exposed group (95 [19%] vs. 77 [11%]; 1.93, 1.37-2.72, P < 0.001).
According to the ICD-10 coding, 20 (4%) patients in the exposed group had respiratory diseases ("J" group) and 21 (4%) congenital malformations ("Q" group), respectively; while both these figures were 9 (1%) in the non-exposed group. Frequency of respiratory diseases (OR, 3.12, 95% CI, 1.43-6.80, P = 0.004) and congenital malformations (OR 3.54, 1.58-7.93, P = 0.002) were significantly higher in the exposed group than in the non-exposed (See Table 2).
Our study found that the overall frequency of physical abnormalities is significantly associated with children whose fathers were exposed to mustard gas. Furthermore, there was a significant association between paternal exposure to mustard gas and both respiratory diseases and congenital malformations. Given the widespread use of mustard gas in wartime, the lasting effects may potentially last generations.
Animal and human studies indicate that paternal exposure to certain agents can result in developmental abnormalities in progenies . Several studies demonstrated that exposure of male rats and mice to cyclophosphamide can lead to congenital malformations in progenies [17, 18]. In humans, paternal exposure to various agents such as acrylamide, lead, and solvents result in an increase in congenital malformations [19–21]. A mechanism suggested for the effect of paternal preconception exposure is the occurrence of transmissible genetic changes or an epigenetic mechanism [22–24].
Possible explanation of findings
Sulfur mustard is a cytotoxic agent with mutagenic and carcinogenic effects . Its active intermediate, sulfonium ion, reacts rapidly with proteins and nucleic acids, alters chemical functional groups such as amines, carboxyls, phosphates, S-H, and O-H groups, and produces alkylation products. This process may result in cross-linking between adjacent strands of DNA, which has been shown to be extremely lethal to cells ;
Confirmed effects of sulfur mustard gas on spermatogenesis may explain the observed overall increase in physical abnormalities among the progenies of chemical victims [2, 12, 25, 26]. However, few studies, previously performed, were conclusive in determining a causal relationship. Pour-Jafari et al.  studied the rate of congenital malformations among progenies and their parents of Iranian victims before and after chemical warfare exposure and found that the rate of major malformations has increased from 33 per 1000 to 258 per 1000. Although they had used his cases as their own controls, and thus reduced selection bias, they did not adjust for the effect of parents' increasing age on malformation occurrence. Taher et al claimed that the use of mustard gas in the Iran-Iraq conflict might have increased the number of cleft lip and cleft palate in children, however, they were not able to establish any causal effect between these two events, nor could they exclude the effects of other possible causes.
Strengths & Limitations
Strengths of our study include its sample size and locally relevant controls. Sardasht is one of the rare instances in the world with a large population of mustard gas victims. Despite initial resistance to studying the effects of exposure, overtime, initial politico-ethical resistance has faded. No similar study has yet been performed with this population. Furthermore, presence of an unexposed population in a nearby city (Rabat) with characteristics similar to the exposed group provided a unique opportunity to further strengthen this analysis. An inherent limitation of studies like this, where the participants may consider probable benefits by over-reporting adverse outcomes, and also where a long time is passed from the date of the event under investigation, is the possibility of recall bias. We aimed to minimize these biases by an inclusive physical exam and appropriate paraclinical studies performed by GPs and further confirmation by a pediatrician. However, our exposed group included only the progenies of those exposed males who were present in the city at the time of study. Moreover, we do not know the number of men exposed that died or moved since exposure. We used clinical examination and paraclinical tests of live birth children to determine disorders and malformations. It is possible that kariotyping and other genetic studies could have revealed more problems [25, 29]. It is also possible that miscarriages or abortions would have yielded differing effects. Finally, it is possible that our control population differs importantly from the exposed population that we have not recognized. This issue exists with any non-randomized comparison and we are unable to overcome this concern.
Our study found a significant association between exposure to mustard gas and common disorders and malformations. We did not find that any specific disorder or malformation was associated with exposure. We expected this as, with anencephaly, for example, there is a prevalence rate of about one in 1000 live births , thus, even with a doubling of risk rates, a much greater population would need to be studied to reveal strong association with chemical exposure. Considering the high number of chemical victims in Iran, this study may catalyze further comprehensive assessments with larger study populations. Using a post hoc sample size calculation, we find that our study had greater than 95% power to detect malformations and greater than 99% power to detect malformations/disorders.
We evaluated all clinical disorders and malformations, regardless of hypothesis driven associations with chemical exposure. Our reasoning for this is that the link between genetic disorders and resulting illnesses is not yet completely understood. So, for example, while rheumatic fever with congenital involvement may be most often associated with communicable disease genesis, we cannot rule out that parental chemical exposure may be associated with predispositions to certain illnesses .
Our study found a significant association between overall frequency of physical abnormalities and disorders and paternal exposure to mustard gas. Given the considerable victims of mustard gas among Iranian civilians and military personnel, as well as civilians and military in other conflicts, the effects of war may have a lasting and important effect on generations to come.
The Board of Research Ethics in the Janbazan Medical and Engineering Research Center (JMERC) and Shahed University approved this study. Informed written consent was obtained from all the parents and caregivers involved in this study.
Aguiar MJ, Campos AS, Aguiar RA, Lana AM, Magalhaes RL, Babeto LT: Neural tube defects and associated factors in liveborn and stillborn infants]. J Pediatr (Rio J). 2003, 79: 129-34. 10.1590/S0021-75572003000200007.
Azizi F, Keshavarz A, Roshanzamir F, Nafarabadi M: Reproductive function in men following exposure to chemical warfare with sulphur mustard. Med War. 1995, 11: 34-44.
United Nations Security Council: Report of the mission dispatched by the secretary-general to investigate allegations of the use of chemical weapons in the conflict between the Islamic Republic of Iran and Iraq. 1987, New York: United Nations
Donovan JW, MacLennan R, Adena M: Vietnam service and the risk of congenital anomalies. A case-control study. Med J Aust. 1984, 140: 394-7.
Cowan DN, DeFraites RF, Gray GC, Goldenbaum MB, Wishik SM: The risk of birth defects among children of Persian Gulf War veterans. N Engl J Med. 1997, 336: 1650-6. 10.1056/NEJM199706053362306.
Balali-Mood M, Navaeian A: Clinical and practical findings in 233 patients with sulfur mustard poisoning. Proceedings of the 2nd World Congress on New Compounds in Biological and Chemical Warfare: Toxicological Evaluation, Industrial Chemical Disasters, Civil Protection and Treatment. 1986, Ghent, Belgium, State University of Ghent
Erickson JD, Mulinare J, McClain PW: Vietnam veterans' risks for fathering babies with birth defects. JAMA. 1984, 252: 903-12. 10.1001/jama.252.7.903.
Ghanei M, Fathi H, Mohammad MM, Aslani J, Nematizadeh F: Long-term respiratory disorders of claimers with subclinical exposure to chemical warfare agents. Inhal Toxicol. 2004, 16: 491-5. 10.1080/08958370490442421.
Ghanei M, Rajaee M, Khateri S, Alaeddini F, Haines D: Assessment of fertility among mustard-exposed residents of Sardasht, Iran: a historical cohort study. Reprod Toxicol. 2004, 18: 635-9. 10.1016/j.reprotox.2004.03.003.
Heston W: Induction of pulmonary tumors in strain A mice with methyl bis (beta-chloroethyl) amine hydrochloride. J Natl Cancer Inst. 1949, 10: 125-30.
Zarchi K, Akbar A, Naieni KH: Long-term pulmonary complications in combatants exposed to mustard gas: a historical cohort study. Int J Epidemiol. 2004, 33: 579-81. 10.1093/ije/dyh068.
Karalliedde L, Wheeler H, Maclehose R, Murray V: Possible immediate and long-term health effects following exposure to chemical warfare agents. Public Health. 2000, 114: 238-48. 10.1016/S0033-3506(00)00338-3.
Khateri S, Ghanei M, Keshavarz S, Soroush M, Haines D: Incidence of lung, eye, and skin lesions as late complications in 34,000 Iranians with wartime exposure to mustard agent. J Occup Environ Med. 2003, 45: 1136-43. 10.1097/01.jom.0000094993.20914.d1.
Sasser LB, Cushing JA, Dacre JC: Two-generation reproduction study of sulfur mustard in rats. Reprod Toxicol. 1996, 10: 311-9. 10.1016/0890-6238(96)00060-3.
Gross CL, Nealley EW, Nipwoda MT, Smith WJ: Pretreatment of human epidermal keratinocytes with D, L-sulfuraphane protects against sulfur mustard sytotoxicity. Cutan Ocul Toxicol. 2006, 25: 155-63. 10.1080/15569520600859985.
Anderson D: Male-mediated developmental toxicity. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol. 2005, 207: 506-13. 10.1016/j.taap.2005.01.022.
Jenkinson PC, Anderson D: Malformed foetuses and karyotype abnormalities in the offspring of cyclophosphamide and allyl alcohol-treated male rats. Mutat Res. 1990, 229: 173-84.
Jenkinson PC, Anderson D, Gangolli SD: Increased incidence of abnormal foetuses in the offspring of cyclophosphamide-treated male mice. Mutat Res. 1987, 188: 57-62. 10.1016/0165-1218(87)90115-7.
Tornquist M: Chem Res Toxicol. 2002, 13: 517-22.
Uzych L: Teratogenesis and mutagenesis associated with the exposure of human males to lead: a review. Yale J Biol Med. 1985, 58: 9-17.
Brender JD, Suarez L: Paternal occupation and anencephaly. Am J Epidemiol. 1990, 131: 517-21.
Mageroy N, Mollerlokken OJ, Riise T, Koefoed V, Moen BE: A higher risk of congenital anomalies in the offspring of personnel who served aboard a Norwegian missile torpedo boat. Occup Environ Med. 2006, 63: 92-7. 10.1136/oem.2005.021113.
Kircher M, Brendel M: DNA alkylation by mustard gas in yeast strains of different repair capacity. Chem Biol Interact. 1983, 44: 27-39. 10.1016/0009-2797(83)90127-8.
Wormser U, Izrael M, Van der Zee EA, Brodsky B, Yanai J: A chick model for the mechanisms of mustard gas neurobehavioral teratogenicity. Neurotoxicol Teratol. 2005, 27: 65-71. 10.1016/j.ntt.2004.09.006.
Rall DP, Pechura CM: Effects on health of mustard gas. Nature. 1993, 366: 398-9. 10.1038/366398b0.
Safarinejad MR: Testicular effect of mustard gas. Urology. 2001, 58: 90-4. 10.1016/S0090-4295(01)01085-8.
Pour-Jafari H: Congenital malformations in the progenies of Iranian chemical victims. Vet Hum Toxicol. 1994, 36: 562-3.
Taher AA: Cleft lip and palate in Tehran. Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 1992, 29: 15-6. 10.1597/1545-1569(1992)029<0015:CLAPIT>2.3.CO;2.
Watson AP, Jones TD, Griffin GD: Sulfur mustard as a carcinogen: application of relative potency analysis to the chemical warfare agents H, HD, and HT. Regul Toxicol Pharmacol. 1989, 10: 1-25. 10.1016/0273-2300(89)90010-X.
Nayar S, Nayar PG, Cherian KM: Heart valve structure: a predisposing factor for rheumatic heart disease. Heart. 2006, 92: 1151-2. 10.1136/hrt.2005.075358.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
HA, MHR, MR, PS, HG, MRS, FF, YT, AS, SMK, ZK conceived the study. HA, MHR, MR, PS, HG, MRS, FF, YT, AS, SMK, ZK designed and conducted the data collection. HA, MHR, MR, PS, HG, MRS, FF, YT, AS, SMK, ZK, MJ, FMB, EJM conducted data analysis. HA, MHR, MR, PS, HG, MRS, FF, YT, AS, SMK, ZK, MJ, FMB, EJM wrote the drafts of the manuscript and approved the final submitted version.
About this article
Cite this article
Abolghasemi, H., Radfar, M.H., Rambod, M. et al. Childhood physical abnormalities following paternal exposure to sulfur mustard gas in Iran: a case-control study. Confl Health 4, 13 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1186/1752-1505-4-13
- Congenital Malformation
- Exposed Group
- Chemical Exposure
- Sulfur Mustard
- Nearby City